I was scammed by an artist on Fiverr who I hired to create original artwork for a book cover. The seller presented their services as legitimate, and nothing initially raised any red flags. However, when I received the first draft, I noticed that the artwork appeared to be AI-generated rather than original artwork created by the artist.
I confronted the seller about the use of AI, and that was when the situation became even more problematic. Instead of receiving a straightforward resolution, I had difficulty getting the issue properly addressed.
I also had a frustrating experience with Fiverr’s customer service. Their response felt heavily biased in favor of AI-generated work and did not adequately address my concern that I had paid an artist for artwork that I believed was supposed to be created by the artist themselves. The process of trying to get help and resolve the situation was extremely difficult and left me feeling that both the seller and Fiverr had failed to be transparent about what I was actually paying for.
As an independent author, paying for professional cover art is a significant expense. I expected transparency about how the artwork would be produced, and I feel that I should have been informed upfront if AI was going to be used.
I confronted Fiverr’s customer service because the artist repeatedly refused to cancel the order, even after admitting that AI had been used to create the artwork. I requested cancellation multiple times, but the artist kept rejecting my requests. After this happened several times, I escalated the matter to Fiverr’s customer service.
Unfortunately, Fiverr also refused to give me a full or even partial refund. Their reasoning was essentially that because AI was used to produce the artwork, the seller had still technically completed the job, even though the use of AI had not been disclosed in the gig and was not what I believed I was paying for.
I spent a considerable amount of time arguing with customer service, but eventually realized I was getting nowhere. I also found videos and reports from other people describing very similar experiences with Fiverr, including customers who discovered that work they paid artists to create was AI-generated and were unable to get their money back. This made it clear to me that my experience was not an isolated incident.
Then I realized there was one specific point in the seller’s own gig description that I could use to challenge the situation: the seller explicitly advertised “100% commercial use rights.”
That claim became important because the artwork was AI-generated. If a seller is promising 100% commercial use rights, that implies the customer is receiving artwork they can actually use commercially and have appropriate rights over. However, AI-generated material can raise serious copyright and ownership limitations, meaning the customer may not be able to obtain copyright protection over the AI-generated portions in the same way they could with human-created artwork.
I brought this issue directly to both the artist and Fiverr customer service. I argued that advertising “100% commercial use rights” while providing undisclosed AI-generated artwork was misleading because the rights being advertised were not equivalent to what a customer would receive if the artwork were genuinely created by the artist.
At that point, I essentially turned the same argument back on them: if the gig promises 100% commercial use rights, but the seller provides AI-generated material that may not be copyrightable, then the gig's description is misleading at best. That specific claim became the strongest point I had to challenge the transaction.
This strengthened my argument and kept the dispute going for several more hours. At that point, customer service no longer seemed to have a response to the issue I was raising. Eventually, they had no other solution but to give me a full refund and close the order.
After fighting with both the seller and Fiverr for hours, I finally found the loophole that got me out of the situation.
If anyone else finds themselves in a similar situation, this is the argument I would recommend looking into: pay close attention to the rights and guarantees advertised in the gig itself. In my case, the seller specifically promised “100% commercial use rights,” and that became the key point I used to challenge the order after discovering that the artwork was AI-generated.
I had tried repeatedly to resolve the issue through the normal cancellation and refund process, and I got nowhere. It was only when I challenged the specific claims made in the gig description that I was finally able to get my money back.